« Previous entry  |  Home  |  Next entry »

The Golden Gate Bridge and the Suicide Barrier

Yesterday I received an email from Richard at Sparkletack, a fantastic podcast about San Francisco history, asking for listener feedback by way of a vote for our three favorite episodes.

One of my three choices is The Golden Gate Bridge, a Modest Proposal. From pretty much the time it opened in the 30's, the bridge has been a suicide magnet and there has been an endless debate about whether to build a suicide barrier fence.

There are a lot of reasons given not to put up a barrier. It would be too expensive (several million dollars with all the studies), it would just lead people to commit suicide elsewhere, but there's one reason which really bothers me: it would ruin the beauty of the bridge.

Photo of razor-wire on the Golden Gate Bridge
Photograph by Rick

I'm lucky enough, living so close, I cross it every few weeks when cycling over to Marin County, and it never fails to impress me. For everyone who makes this trip, on a bike or by foot, the first several hundred yards is already obstructed by a fence. And it's not an attractive one either. Unlike the barrier concepts which have already been developed, designed to match the art deco style and make a minimal impact on the view, it's a plain cyclone fence topped with "no trespassing" signs and topped with razor-wire.

Those who want to preserve the beauty of the bridge should be in support of a barrier fence, if for no other reason than to replace the ugly fencing which currently greets visitors as they start there trip across.

I'm not going to spoil the proposal in Richard's podcast, but perhaps a less hostile greeting to visitors could play it's own part in preventing suicide.

6 Comments

pkh Tuesday, August 7, 2007 at 9:18pm

One person dies five days at the Golden Gate Bridge.

The solution is simple raise the rail - or close the walkway. Over 1,500 are estimated to have died to date many have never been found so there is no true accounting.

The view that people will just go some where else does not stand the test of logic. Suicide is an impetuous act - 98% of those stopped never try it again.

Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.
It is epidemic among teens that see the world as an impossible place to negotiate.

And if you can not get beyond that just think of the families that are forever ruined due to the horrible death of a loved one - the collateral damage is incalculable.

Would a sane society permit someone to leave a loaded gun in a psychiatric ward? Of course not -

The rail is too low its temptation too high and the apathy surrounding death at the Bridge to great.

Death at the Bridge is about the most horrible one could imagine. Victims usually drown in their own blood, screaming due to the pain from the loss of a limb or due to having their bones crushed at impact.

But their screams aren’t heard due as the water fills their lungs as they are washed out to sea never to be seen again.

Brian Protheroe Wednesday, August 8, 2007 at 7:46pm

I'm not opposed to the barrier, in fact I wouldn't stand it the way of such a creation. But, we must admit, those who are determined to take their own lives will find another way to do it if "the bridge" is not available for that purpose. Not a nice thought, but still true. Just my two cents.

Brian

Anonymous Thursday, August 9, 2007 at 8:29pm

Just a few moments ago, I found out that an old childhood friend took his life by jumping off the bridge on August 7, 2007. In my opinion, the barrier is really important. While, it may not prevent someone from taking his or her own life, it does elimintate an option. One would not be able to use the bridge to end one's life, a novel idea.

teslagirl Thursday, August 9, 2007 at 8:52pm

Anonymous: your post gave me chills. I was there the other day. It's the whole reason I came across this site. I'm so sorry for your loss.

pkh Monday, August 13, 2007 at 10:20pm

Suicide is an impetuous act – or the act of an ill person lacking the capacity to make a sane decision. Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.

Limiting access to the means of death has proven to dramatically reduce suicides.
98% of those stopped never attempt suicide again.

The rails at the Golden Gate Bridge are simply too low and access is too great. The rails of the bridge need to be raised.

Four people try to die there every week and one succeeds.

The true victims are the loved ones left behind many of which carry terrible emotional scars the rest of their lives...

San Franciscans and the people of the Bay Area can no longer hide their collective heads in the sand - we are now well aware of the horror taking place and as such have a moral obligation to do something to end the deaths at the Golden Gate Bridge.

Please help raise the rails - and end the tragic deaths

Laura Monday, September 24, 2007 at 10:28pm

Anonymous,
I'm very sorry for the loss of your friend. August 7 is my birthday, so hearing that creeped me out. It made me sad to think, I'm celebrating life, while someone else is trying to end their's. Life can be tough, I know there's been time's when I said, "life sucks, and what's the point." I think weather and location has a lot to do with people's mood's. I don't think the suicide barrier is going to deter jumpers, they'll just find another way.

Post a Comment


(You can use the HTML tags for bold, italic and links)

(never shown, ever)

(if you have one)

    (clear)

« Previous entry | Home | Next entry »

The page you're looking at is a blog entry by me, Jamison, and part of my web site Adventures in Urban Living.

View other entries I've categorized San Francisco or posted in August 2007.

Bookmark this entry with del.icio.us, Newsvine or Digg.

RSSSubscribe to RSS feed
Contact meContact me

 

Recent Entries

Checking the Facts
Friday, October 3, 2008

A rainbow of iPods
Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Miniature on miniature action
Monday, September 8, 2008

Milk
Thursday, September 4, 2008

The New California Academy of Sciences
Thursday, August 21, 2008

Elsewhere

Most of my photos make it onto my Flickr photostream if they aren't here and I've been putting interesting links into my Del.icio.us bookmarks.

If you like using an RSS feed reader you can subscribe to my site.

RSSSite RSS feed

Recent Photographs

Alexis
Photobooth
Mission Accomplished
Brushes
Shag
Lego my Mecha

I post a selection of photographs here. Many more can be found in my Flickr photostream

Recent Entries

Checking the Facts
October 3, 2008

A rainbow of iPods
September 9, 2008

Miniature on miniature action
September 8, 2008

Milk
September 4, 2008

Archived Entries

Browse Categories

Browse by Month

Green Web Hosting! This site hosted by DreamHost.

Powered by Movable Type and hosted with DreamHost, a green web hosting company.

This site is licensed under a Creative Common Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives License